Skip to content Skip to footer
TPSP logo

Description of Unit

Students will understand living and non-living systems and patterns found in systems. They will use technical writing and statistics to produce a scientific paper and formal presentation.

This guide links the Challenging the System unit to the Texas Essential Knowledge and Skills (TEKS) for eighth graders. Challenging the System is a science unit that allows students to explore living and nonliving systems and the roles those systems play in the environment and society. Though a science unit, Challenging the System also teaches students skills in the other subject areas of English language arts, mathematics, and social studies. For example, students use graphs, tables, and statistical data, which the Mathematics TEKS include, and writing and research skills, which the English Language Arts and Reading and Social Studies TEKS require. The following document includes the applicable TEKS and the details of the Challenging the System unit. The asterisks indicate that those TEKS are testable on the State of Texas Assessments of Academic Readiness (STAAR). The final section of this document presents the applicable Texas College and Career Readiness Standards adopted by the Texas Higher Education Coordinating Board (THECB) on January 24, 2008.

Phase I. Learning Experiences

A system is a collection of cycles, structures, and processes that interact. Students should understand a whole system in terms of its components and how these components relate to each other and to the whole. All systems have basic properties that can be described in terms of space, time, energy, and matter. Change and constancy occur in systems and can be observed and measured as patterns. These patterns help to predict what will happen next and can change over time.

Students will need prior knowledge of and experience in various science concepts:

  • Systems
  • The scientific process
  • Analysis of existing data
  • The use of data to make predictions
  • Understanding of graphically-presented data
  • Technical writing, as appropriate for science
  • Scientific vocabulary

Opening activity. In groups, students analyze or create a system, such as a Rube Goldberg invention. Teachers should design this activity to fit the course students are taking. Each group must draw or create a model of their system. Then, each group will present to the class. Encourage students to ask questions about the necessity of each part of the system. Debrief. What are the things you know about a system (all the parts must work together, a system performs a function of some kind, systems are dependent on other systems, etc.)?

If you choose to do a Rube Goldberg invention, see these websites for examples:
http://mousetrapcontraptions.com/
http://www.rube-goldberg.com/

Phase II. Independent Research

A. Research process

  1. Selecting a topic. Each student identifies a problem within a system that he/she wishes to study. The problem should be a real-world problem (heart disease in humans, the thinning of the ozone layer, erosion of beach dunes, water pollution from catfish farms, etc.). Depending on the topic the student wishes to study, the system could be biological, physical, environmental, social, or other.
  2. Asking guiding questions. Once the student has selected a topic, he/she should think of three to five guiding questions to explore, such as:
    • What are the causes of this problem?
    • What factors contribute positively or negatively to the problem?
    • What are the consequences of this problem?
    • What are some solutions?
    • What are the advantages and disadvantages of each solution?
    • How could the solutions lead to new problems?
    While these examples are general, the student’s questions should be specific to the chosen topic. The questions should lead him/her to form individual research-based opinions. The student should also develop a hypothesis or some possible answers to the questions.
  3. Designing and submitting a research proposal. The student should include numerous components in the research proposal:
    • The real-world problem to be investigated
    • Three to five guiding questions he/she will investigate
    • Resources he/she will need to find answers to questions, such as previous studies on the topic and/or correspondence with experts on the subject
    • A process for gathering data to inform potential solutions to the problem, such as an experimental design or a survey.
    In the process of writing the research proposal, students may refine their guiding questions and research process.
  4. Conducting the research. After the teacher has approved student proposals, students begin using the resources they have identified and others they may encounter. During this stage, students will need to keep a log, note cards, or resource process sheets of all the sources they use and what they learn from each one.
  5. Data summary. Depending on the topic and needed data, this may be a lab report or analysis of survey results.

B. The product

The student shows what he/she has learned through one of the following written products:

  1. A letter to a person or organization with responsibility for the problem. In the letter, the student should describe the solution that would best solve the problem and give reasons why this solution is the best of all the available solutions. Students may wish to include supplementary materials (such as graphs, tables, and/or visual depictions of the system) with the letter and should mail the letter to the appropriate person or organization. The student should also include any response from or additional communication with the person or organization.
  2. An article that summarizes the results of the research. The student should use graphs, tables, or visual depictions of the system to illustrate the research process, results, and conclusions. The article should be submitted to a publication (e.g., school newspaper, community newspaper through a letter to the editor, teen magazine, online journal). The student should also include any response from or additional communication with representatives from the publication.

    Whatever product is chosen, the student must complete a Reference List/Works Cited Page that includes at least ten references.

C. Communication

The student demonstrates what he/she has learned through one of the following types of presentations, to last no more than fifteen minutes:

  1. A formal presentation to a panel of experts. In the class, form panels of “experts”—groups of students or adults—who will read the student’s letter or article, listen to his/her presentation, and ask questions. The student may provide some questions to the panel, but others should be generated by the panel members.
  2. An informal class presentation in which the student presents his/her expertise to the class. A question-and-answer session should follow the presentation.

D. Submission

  1. The cover sheet
  2. A research proposal
  3. A log, note cards, or resource process sheets
  4. A data summary
  5. The letter or article
  6. A Works Cited Page with at least ten references
  7. An audiotape or videotape of presentation, including the Q&A session
  8. A response to the student letter or article, if received
Back to top.